The Smackdown results for Over the Limit: Randy Orton defeats Christian (damn); Sin Cara defeats Chavo; Ezekiel Jackson beat Wade Barrett by DQ (holy cow, a DQ in a Corre match!?), and thus the IC Title does not change hands.
Our show starts, much to my dismay, with the sight of Randy Orton, still World Heavyweight Champion. Damnation. It seems that the writers have realized that Orton cannot talk, as the total amount of words he gets out this evening are: “My name is Randy Orton, and I’m still Champion.” You see, Randy Orton thinks he’s Alberto Del Rio. Mercifully, Orton is unable to continue as Christian interrupts him. I can now see the writing on the wall that they are going to try and turn Christian heel, and it drives me crazy, as he is by far the most marketable face they have right now, and it’s mind boggling that no one in front office can see this. At any rate, at least it’s not just a knee jerk heel turn, as they seem to be going through narrative stages in order to pull it off. Christian comes out and, very classily, admits that Orton beat him fair and square, yet he is still of the opinion that he can regain his title. So, basically, they’re going the route of making Christian a sore loser. Which doesn’t remotely make sense to me, because most everyone (except the twerps in the audience who are booing him) know that Christian is the one who got screwed over in all of this in favour of Orton, who really didn’t need this title reign. So, yeah, this is a heel turn that very few can get behind. At least with Truth, in spite of my reluctance, his character needed something of a push, and it wound up working out with his turning crazy. With Christian, we’re all still teary eyed from him and Edge’s good bye, and want nothing more than to see him succeed. I mean, people have been waiting for years to see Christian as Champion, and you’d have to be insane to truly want to see this man fail. Anyways, it seems that it’s time to do the “No, /I/ should be the #1 Contender!” thing, because here comes Sheamus, who says that all Christian has proven at Over the Limit is that he’s a two time loser, who spent seventeen years to master the art of losing. Harsh, but good heat building. Sheamus also points out it only took him two years to become a two time Champion, and he has all the credentials needed to get a push. But, here comes the last of our Big Four, Mark Henry. Boy, has anyone benefitted from the lack of other main eventers quite as much as Mark Henry? To be at the top card by sheer process of elimination... Mark again shows that he’s becoming more convincing on the microphone by talking about how when you’re the World’s Strongest Man, you don’t wait at the back of the line, you butt ahead. Because, he asks, who exactly is going to say you can’t?
So we have an impasse, which beckons Teddy Long to make a decision. Of course, Teddy’s response to this is to /not/ make a decision, instead deciding that a Triple Threat match will determine who will face Orton next week in a Title Match. What exactly do you do that’s effective, Teddy?
Our first match of the evening is between Sin Cara and Chavo Guerrero. This is pretty much the perfect match: the moves used by both men are varied and interesting, the pacing is constant, there are counters galore (thus showing that both men know what they’re doing, and adds an extra level of intrigue to the match), a good mix of high flying and technical moves, there is always something happening, and the speed makes it all the more exciting. Furthermore, the pair got to go longer than most opening matches, yet they managed to maintain the same standard of quality throughout, not bogging down or becoming tedious. The only thing I was a bit let down with was the finish, with Sin Cara winning with a modified DDT. It just seemed less impressive than his usual backflip off the top rope. Nonetheless, I have been consistently impressed by Sin Cara’s ringwork.
After this great match, we have another great match, Cody Rhodes vs. Daniel Bryan. There, see? I knew Smackdown could pull through if it was given time. They’ve found out who works well together, and are trucking along with it. Strangely, Ted doesn’t come out with Cody this time, which is a pity, as I was hoping that would become a thing. Cody does win line of the night, as he enters with: “If I didn’t know any better, I’d say there is no God, because my prayers to find at least one decent looking person in the audience are continuously unanswered.” This is another well-done technical match, with both men showing off impressive movesets and always seem to pull something new out of the hat. My favourite moment was when Daniel Bryan did his usual backflip off the ringpost, only to have Cody follow in kind and deliver a knee to Bryan’s face. The ending was a bit off, though, as Bryan goes to lock in the LeBell Lock, and Cody taps out before it’s fully in. I imagine it had to be a planned thing, as the commentary picks up on it and discusses it (Booker hazards a guess that it was a way for Cody to end the match quickly without actually having to feel the pain), but the motivations are never made clear, so I don’t know if it’s a flub or what. At any rate, Cody, of course, reacts poorly, and bludgeons Bryan before putting a paper bag on his head. That would be the weirdest Mortal Kombat fatality move ever.
Well, we’ve had our quality for the evening. Now for the Corre. Specifically, Ezekiel Jackson vs. Heath Slater. I was a bit confused while watching this, because the pacing is kept up relatively fast, and there is always something happening, so it felt like it was a better match than it actually was. After watching it again, though, you can see that not a whole lot is really happening. It’s just Jackson delivering some punches and general power moves, and Slater getting in a really mediocre offense. I’m still not impressed with either man. And, as it is a Corre match, you’ll never guess how this one ends. I’ll give you a hint: It starts with D, and ends in Q. Yes, here comes the gang to save Ginger yet again. They try to go for the fearsome Corre stomp, but Zeke drives all three of them off, standing alone in the ring. I guess what they’re going for here is that Zeke stood his ground. Sadly, as I don’t care about Zeke, and since the Corre has never been a potent force, the effect is lost.
Thank God, it’s Kane time. Sadly, the Big Show is actually injured, and so their Tag Team will be on hiatus for a while. This is a pity, as the definitely gave the Tag Team Titles some meaning again. Well, Kane’s looking to kill things, and here’s the Great Khali. Much like any Khali match, Kane does the work, Khali generally no-sells it, but much to my surprise, Kane gets to Chokeslam Khali for the win. Well, didn’t see that coming. Thank you, Kane. Now, go and find out what happened to Undertaker. Once again Jinder Idon’tcare comes out to berate Khali, this time winning him over as Khali takes out his former manager, Ranjin Singh, and walks away, now a heel. Oh, no! Now he can be boring /and/ evil! The horror.
We then get a pointless scene in which Booker is in the ring, taunting Cole for losing to King. It’s over in about a minute. I don’t get it, either.
So, with Kharma apparently down for at least nine months, it’s time to start rebuilding in Diva Land. Since we’ve made such leaps and strides over the last few months, surely things can only improve, right?
Our match tonight is Alicia Fox and Tamina vs. Kaitlyn and AJ. Who are those two, you ask? Well, Kaitlyn won NXT Season 3, though she can’t wrestle, and AJ was a runner up. They’re being managed by Natalya. This match consists of Kaitlyn pushing and shoving Alicia, and then Alicia comes back and gets the win. Now, allow me to break this down: Natalya, who put on a clinic last week, is at ringside and doesn’t get into the action. Tamina, who is also decent, does not get in. Our protagonist in this match is all but useless. Our heel here, who wins cleanly, is Alicia Fox, who is built like a mop.
Damnation, Kharma, why did you have to go and get pregnant!?
Seriously, this is one giant step backwards for the women’s division. We were on the cusp of putting all the good Divas ahead, and now our fearsome bad-girl is Alicia Fox? She’s not even remotely intimidating! Surely we can have more compelling plotlines than this? Surely? I can only hope that Natalya isn’t doing to be designated to managing for long, because she can definitely pick up the women’s division and run with it if given a chance.
Main event time. The match starts off much as you’d expect, with Mark Henry and Sheamus pummelling Christian. And here is where things aren’t making a great deal of sense: if they /are/ going to try and make Christian heel, why are they still making him the obvious sympathetic hero? I’m all for giving a character angles, but not when he should so plainly be the good guy out of all of this. True to his heroic form, Christian battles on, getting Sheamus out of the ring and focusing on Mark Henry. Thinking on it, a Triple Threat match with these three has a multitude of pacing possibilities, given the fast, medium, and slow performances that Christian, Sheamus, and Mark are generally capable of. The match seems to go with the medium setting, as they try and keep the action constant (as they should, when there are three men in the ring), opting for the strategy of having one man outside the ring while the other two do battle inside, and then subbing in when one needs a breather. I like how Christian can play to the speeds of the other two, going in stride with their moves, instead of speeding it up too much and then having us crash when we slow down again. It’s just a good, steady pace.
And then, for no adequately explained reason, out comes Randy Orton to sit at ringside. Thankfully, as I mentioned before, the writers are aware that the man is as boring as mud, and thus they don’t bother putting him on guest commentary. Of course, that doesn’t explain why he’s here, but regardless. The match continues perfectly fine in the ring, including the implosion of Team Heel, with Sheamus and Mark going after one another. At one point, Mark is outside of the ring, and for reasons not specified (or, if they were, it was off camera) slaps Randy Orton. Actually, you know what? I don’t need a narrative reason for Mark Henry to slap Orton. I can take it as it is. Unfortunately, this will have consequences, and will further confuse and complicate the matter over who’s the good guy and who’s heel here. Christian Spears Sheamus, and quite clearly has him pinned for three, but in the meantime, Orton has interfered and RKO’d Mark Henry, which has the ref’s attention, so no one is doing the counting, and Sheamus kicks out at twenty six. Now, credit where it’s due, if they are going to turn Christian heel, at least they’re doing it with him being constantly screwed over by factors that aren’t his fault. It’s enough to drive any man mad. That’s fine, even though I disagree with it, because it makes sense for the character and the role he is to undertake. It’s like when they turned Punk heel, and took it gradually and methodically to develop his character to a point where it all worked believably. What doesn’t make sense here is how they can possibly justify keeping Orton as the protagonist in all of this! He just screwed over Christian, and we all saw it, and it was for no better reason than he selfishly wanted his revenge against Mark Henry, and couldn’t wait until the match was over. Orton constantly acts in selfish, douche-bag like ways, and I don’t see how anyone can consider him hero material. And no, the answer “He’s an anti-hero” does not apply, because even anti-heroes have to do something remotely heroic every now and again, and Orton does none of that. He’s still doing everything he did as the ultimate bad guy, he’s just not being condemned for it by the writers. Moreover, in this plotline between him and Christian, how is Christian not the sympathetic one that we want to see win?! The writing in this plotline is just confused in who it wants to back and for the reasons to do so.
Oh, and, uh, Sheamus wins. Cool.
Actually, I’d be more happy with Sheamus winning this match if I thought it was going to really mean something. As it is, it looks like it’s going to be little more than a stepping stone in the Christian/Orton plot. Now, if I were writing this, I’d have kept Orton from interfering in the match, had Mark Henry cost Christian his pin fall, thus leading to a plotline between those two while keeping Orton vs. Sheamus for a while longer. That way, we could keep Christian face, and thus avoid the heel turn which I’m positive is coming.
So that was Smackdown. In spite of my discontent of Orton, this was a good show. The main event was well done, and the two opening matches were fun. I’m saddened with the Divas match, but I’ll console myself with thinking they’re just in rebuild mode and are going to give me something better next week.